News - Written by Farhan on Saturday, November 29, 2008 15:26 - 9 Comments
Extreme of Irresponsible Reporting!
A very disheartening and irresponsible report from India TV. Have a look
Imagine! Do all the Pakistanis speak in same accent? No!
Urdu accent of Indians is different then the Pakistani Urdu accent? No!
Does Javed Akhtar(Indian Music Lyricist) speak Urdu in a different accent? No!
The word “Qatal-e-Aam” is spoken everyday on ETV Urdu, that’s the Indian channel by the way.
Related Posts
9 Comments
Yes U can’t trace a person’s country identity from his way of speech but another terrorist said clearly that they are from pakistan and also the mobile phone which was found from the terrorist had calls made to karachi..
This Mumbai scenario is pretty sad and yes the people in kashmir have this type of accent!
nik
I have a story to share.
Few years ago my brother who is an salesman visited Kashmir regarding his work and he died there in firing from a militant group. Now if you pakistani people believe that those terrorist are not trained in pakistan and not financed from pakistan, i think you need a serious reality check guys.
On the contrary i am sure India has never trained militants to go and created terror on pakistani soil. If some pakistani has this experinece please share it with me.
A lot of pakistanis are saying that it was past and it doesnt happen any more, But no one is ready to come forward and accept that we did breed terrorists and accept the fact that killed several innocent people. I firmly believe its payback time now for pakistan.
Global Voices Online » Pakistan: Blame Game On Mumbai Terror - The Blogosphere Speaks
[...] the Indian mainstream media has nonetheless been irresponsible with the blame game. At my blog Guppu.com I have posted a video of a sensationalist reporting by the Indian media speculating about accents [...]
MURAD
WELL WHAT IF THEY ARE INDIAN HINDUS ARMY OFFICERS……..
IF A SERVING INDIAN COLONEL CAN BLOW UP THE SUMJHOTA EXPRESS, THE LINK TRAIN WITH INDO-PAK..MURDER 65 PEOPLE.. AND BLOW UP 10 ODD BOMBS IN DEHLI AND RAJHISTAN ..AND OTHER LOCALITIES IN INDIA.. MURDERING FELLOW INDIANS ..JUST SO MUSLIMS GET THE BLAME..AND LATTER BE ARRESTED AND CHARGED BY CBI.THAN WHY NOT THEY BE INVOLVED IN THIS CARNAGE……..NOW REMEMBER ALL THOSES OFFICERS INVESTIGATING THOSE CRIMES(AGAINST THE INDIAN COL) HAVE BEEN MURDERED IN THIS INCIDENT…..
INDIANS SENSELESS PROPAGANDA MEDIA LOVES TO BLAME ELEMENTS IN I.S.I.. WHY DONT THEY EVEN CONSIDER BLAMING THEMSELVES FOR A CHANGE…
ONE MORE THING……
IF ONLY 15 PEOPLE CAN CAUSE SUCH A CARNAGE.. ONLY 5-8 TERRORIST ARE HOLDING BACK 300 COMMANDOS IN TAJ.
IF 3ODD TERRORISTS CAN HOLD ON AND RESIST 30+ COMMANDOS AND HUNDREDS OF COP ON THE GROUND IN A 5 FLOOR APARTMENT FOR MORE THAN 15 HOURS….AND STILL NOT MANAGE TO SAY THE ALL THE INNOCENT HOSTAGES
AND IF 10 ODD TERRORISTS CAN SAIL FROM ACROSS THE BORDER TO THE GATE OF INDIA IN A STUPID RUBBER BOAT AND NOT BE INTERCEPTED …
THAN THIS RAISES A LOT OF QUESTIONS AS REGARDS THE COMPETENCY OF INDIA IN HANDLING ITS BORDERS AND CAPABILTY OF FIGHTING THE BAD GUYS……THEY SEROIUSLY NEED HELP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!NOT A TRADITIONAL SCAPE GOAT AND EXCUSE……
MY SINCERE CONDOLENCES TO THOSE WHO LOST THEIR LIVES IN THIS TRAGEDY..
PZ
I think this is not the time to blame Pakistan as this could result in tension between India and Pakistan. I am think that the Indian government and media needs to act little more maturely and responsibly. We have seen on several occasions in past when India has blamed Pakistan and Pakistan’s intelligence service but on all those occasions it turned out that the Indian army, police or some security or intelligence agency was responsible for attacks in their own country. These revelations came out of Indian government’s own investigative reports. These are facts which can be checked and not just made up stories as Indian government and press seem to be familiar with! We all want peace, harmony and prosperity. If a neighbouring country is instable, it can cause instability in the whole region. Therefore, both Pakistan and India need to work together to find the culprits and bring them to justice.
I feel shame that my country gives permission to run such television. In India we mock this channel and mostly hate watching it.
Its my heartfelt request to pass on this message to terrorists.. Kindly blast this kind of channels and kill the Indian politicians..
Don
I am Indian and honestly, India TV is to Television news what scary movie is to hollywood movies… a spoof. This is highly irresponsible of India TV to make such a mockery of a sad incident like this. I am ashamed of such channels being allowed to carry a tag of the country along with their channel name.
Yugandar
It is unfortunate that so many of you still dont accept the reality. Read any decent world news, you will see Pakistan hand in the Mumbai massacre. ‘The Observer’ UK magazine verified the terrorists identity in Pakistan and published recently. Truth is ISI and Army are out of control. They should report to your Prime Minister. Only then someone will be mature enough to take the blame. Or else, it will be just finger pointing. ISI -> Terrorist –> Govt –> ARMY. It will be in circles. I don’t see a future for your country. Good Luck !
Leave a Reply
Featured, News, terrorism - Feb 5, 2010 21:03 - 2 Comments
Terrorists are the American Agents: Shia Scholars
More In News
- Beware! Don Coming to Punjab
- President Obama’s Ramadan Message
- Youth’s concern over America’s presence in Pakistan
- Ramadan Moon not sighted in Gulf, Middle East
- Jaswant Singh landed in Double Trouble after praising Pakistan founder

Complete nonsense. The channel is just manipulating the news to get more and more subscribers. Accent does not matter, it does not show that person belongs to which country. Even i got friends from India, they also speak Urdu in Pakistani Accent. So does that mean they are pakistanis? Absolutely not. These Tv channels just try to ignite hatred between pakistani and indian people. Even we Pakistanis use indian words because we watch Star Plus. Does that mean hum hindustaan ka nagrik hai?
It’s just that watching channels you get familiar with words and may use in vocabulary.
Think logically people!